Open Letter to the Bollywood Music Industry

Dear Mr./Ms. Music Executive,

First of all, let me compliment you on your pricing strategy so far. You have aced the test on how to price information products. Information products like music are tricky – the content is all in digital form, the fixed costs are high and marginal costs approach zero. How do you price such a thing?

Your current strategy seems to be working well. You have segmented the market according to the listeners’ ability to pay. To each segment you offer a different product (or sometimes the same product) at vastly different prices. I checked prices at different places for the same album – Don. Here’s what I found:

1. Cassettes for the “Aam Aadmi” – Rs. 58 at Indiaplaza.in
2. CDs for the yuppie Indian – Rs. 160 at Indiaplaza.in
3. CDs for NRIs – $ 14.99 at amazon.com which I thought was crazy since the local Indian grocery store in Fremont sells them for $6.
4. Songs for NRIs – $0.99 on iTunes per song. Price of the album is just a sum of all the songs on it, in this case $7.92.

Even if you exclude the Amazon pricing, the highest to lowest ratios are 5 to 7 times. That is an amazing range of prices for what is essentially the same product. You are getting volumes at the low end and milking the high end. Best of both worlds.

But I hope you’ll understand if I as an NRI have a problem being royally ripped off. Luckily, I travel back to India quite often and pick up all my music here at Rs. 160 an album. I wonder what other Indians who don’t get back too often do. Pass USB disks around, I suppose. Lost revenue for you, but hey, who cares, you’re making a buck a song on iTunes.

I understand why you have to sell your songs for $0.99 on iTunes. You don’t have a choice – that’s the only pricing that Apple will allow. It just happens to be totally out of whack with CD music prices in India. And that rankles.

Most people want to buy music legally, if it is made simple and inexpensive for them to get it. Say this to yourself three times every morning after your morning prayers. And then think about your pricing strategy. There is a vast, relatively untapped appetite for Bollywood music amongst NRIs. If you just got rid of your pre-conceived notions.

Your current strategy has another flaw. It offers no legal way for Indians in India to download music.

Digital music in India is going to happen. I can easily visualize millions of portable music players in the hands of a young population with disposable income. With millions of music players in the market, how can there be no place where one can legally download music? iTunes + iPod together don’t work for India – too expensive – so that’s not an option. The way to make it work in India is to do what mobile handset manufacturers did – make it cheap and go for volumes. Matter of fact, it is quite possible that Nokia and Motorola might dominate the mp3 player market as well, as they include them in their cell phones.

As broadband in India truly becomes “broad”, the convenience of downloading music becomes very real. Especially for those people who listen to their music largely on their portable players. They don’t have to go to a store to buy the whole album when they actually want just a couple of songs. They don’t have to then “rip” the music off of the CD and convert it into mp3. And they don’t have to deal with your brittle, cheap CD cases, which break within two days leaving unprotected CDs around getting scratched.

So here are my recommendations for your digital music strategy:

1. Go DRM-less. I wrote about the DRM lock-in issues in an earlier post. I would strongly advise you to go DRM less. You have nothing to lose – DRM-less files are already out there – on every CD that you sell. What are you afraid of?
2. Price it low and fairly. Stop your “sock-it-to-the-NRI” pricing schemes. Eros Music is trying out a new pricing strategy – $0.25 per song outside India and Rs. 19 in India. There are very few songs (only the albums that they own) and the website sucks, but I think they are onto something. I’m not sure what their thinking is behind the discounted dollar price, but the Indian price per song is bang on. At eight songs for an album that would be the fair value of the song. Their album price is the price of a cassette, which is also surprising. But if the dollar price was even $0.50 that would be fair and very attractive. I’d build up my entire collection of Mukesh songs at these prices. Except that Eros won’t have those songs, Saregama would.
3. Think about flexible pricing. Amie Street has an interesting model where the price of a song, DRM-free by the way, goes up as demand goes up. You could experiment with your own pricing schemes. For instance, release a new album only digitally for a week. Charge a higher price for it.
4. Don’t do this on your own. I am not going to go to different sites for Eros, Saregama and Sony music. And don’t form a consortium to build the site either. They never work. Just let the industry know that you (all of you) are open to considering DRM free music downloads. I’ll bet that in three months there will be a dozen existing and new companies who will respond to it and offer to build online music stores.
5. Form an association like the RIAA and prosecute anybody who illegally hosts your music. Ask the Indian government to help in prosecuting people who operate from countries where the IP laws aren’t as strictly enforced.

But the first thing you need to do is get over your fear of piracy. There are a few things you can do to slow it down. Do them. But don’t expect it to go away. Selling DRM free, digital downloads is not going to increase piracy. Once you get over this mental hump, the rest is easy. You’re smart, (you have to be to have come up with your current pricing strategy), you’ll figure it out.

Sincerely,

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to Open Letter to the Bollywood Music Industry

  1. Pingback: DesiPundit » Archives » An Open Letter

  2. Shashikant says:

    Basab,

    One parameter you are missing in the calculation is PPP. On PPP scale,
    $1 = Rs 9 according to CIA’s World Factbook. The picture will be quite different if you take this as exchange rate.

    Like

  3. Basab says:

    Shashikant, PPP is useful in comparing average incomes across countries. Doesn’t quite apply to pricing across countries.

    Like

  4. S Jagadish says:

    Interesting post, Basab. Nice coincidence this. A few weeks ago, I (and a colleague) wrapped up a project we did as part of a part-time MBA course at IIM Bangalore. Here’s the link to our report.

    Replace ‘UNDERSCORE’ in the email address I’m providing with ‘_’ to reach me.

    Like

  5. Sameer says:

    Hi Basab
    In case you’re interested there is a site called http://www.nehaflix.com where they sell bollywood music CD’s for about 4$. I’ve used the site a couple of times,and have been quite satisfied by the service,and quality of CD’s.

    Perhaps an alternative for people who don’t get to go back that often,and also add to the varying list of prices you’ve mentioned.

    Cheers,
    Sameer

    Like

  6. Zeya says:

    Hey Sameer,

    I have comment on your comment. I have used Nehaflix for filfare mag subscritption. And i think its horrible web-site.
    One theyl milked some 70$ for one year subsciption. Only if was more aware. I wud have bough it for 2-3 $ in indian stores. So it was rip-off price. And It was pain to stop renewal.
    I would Say Bad choice.

    Zeya

    Like

  7. Sameer says:

    Hi Zeya
    Thanks for the comment. Sorry to hear about your experience.

    Maybe they’ve improved their service since your experience. You do find some well priced CD’s though on it,atleast the couple of times i’ve bought from there.

    Sameer

    Like

  8. Sanjay B says:

    Airtel Broadband and Mobile, offer a song download service through a partnership with Soundbuzz.com, a Singapore based service provider. I am not sure how the service is doing, but it would very interesting to watch the mobile music download space. I think it is priced at Rs 15 and Rs 20 per song over Broadband and mobile respectively.

    As this post states, with Broadband, proliferating, mobile connections exploding combined with mp3 enabled handsets in every teenage palm, the market is evolving fast. Of the telcos, mobile service providers, handset manufacturers, independent download services – who will create India’s iTunes. We are probably in for another ‘who owns the customer’ tussle!

    Like

  9. Shefaly says:

    As a consumer, I do not care who wins the ‘who owns the customer’ so long as *I* own the song, in all formats, playable across all sorts of devices and so on.

    Like

  10. Karthik says:

    Basab, Glad to know that you are a Mukesh fan. I suggest you join the SingerMukesh yahoo group. You will definitely find some gardcore fans of Mukesh and also people who have interacted closely with Mukesh.

    Like

  11. Sandy says:

    I think Yash Raj Films (www.yashrajfilms.com) offers great music on their website, you can also buy Music and download music as less as 15 rs. Its a steal deal for Yash Raj Fan, who loves timeless melodies and great albums.

    It is a very good site for music

    Like

  12. Basab says:

    Karthik, thanks for the tip. will check it out.

    Sandy, I checked out the YashRaj films website. It seems to be much better designed compared to the Eros music website. With one key difference – it uses Microsoft DRM, which makes it useless for me. I could perhaps download in their format, burn a CD and then convert to mp3 to listen on my iPod. But the two conversions will probably reduce fidelity a tad, plus it is too much trouble.

    Incidentally, in case anyone from YashRaj is listening, the same process I describe above can be used by anyone who wants to either put the pirated music on a website or just share the files with friends. So the question is – why wouldn’t you let an honest paying customer like me download in a DRM free format?

    Like

  13. Brett lee says:

    I have gone through the above site which gives good information about music cassettes and their prices and i have gone through the similar site site which gives good information about music and their prices .

    Digitalmusic

    Like

  14. Just Mohit says:

    Hi Basab, really thoughtful post. BTW, for most older albums do try out emusic.com. Unfortunately, for the new releases, because of the music industry’s desire to fleece NRI’s, people will continue flocking to papuyaar.com etc.

    Like

  15. Anuradha says:

    All, Check this out http://www.beatofindia.com/

    These guys are trying to promote FolK music online. They allow you to hear a small piece and based on that you can buy the song/music piece.

    Like

  16. Pingback: Desi Galaxy » Bollywood Links Round up

  17. Gaurav says:

    HI Basab
    You can legally download digital music in India and at a fair price. check soundbuzz.com. Infact it allows you to download singles from an album.
    The only catch? DRM protected restricts transfer from original download destination to your mobile phone memory card

    Like

  18. Pingback: desi galaxy » Blog Archive » Bollywood Links Round up

  19. There is a new medium to watch Hindi movies online.

    Try http://www.interval.in – India’s premier movie portal

    Relax, take a break at Interval
    Enjoy!

    Like

  20. nrifun says:

    all user watching online videos and serial film industry.
    Hindi Movies, Punjabi Films, Desi Videos, Bollywood Movies, Hindi Films, Telugu, Tamil, hindi Tv Serials, Pakistani, Free Download – Nrifun.com

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s